What is a Dog Training Collar and How it Works
Unlike the usual cotton or nylon dog collars that you can usually find in a pet store, a dog training collar, or more popularly known as a shock collar, is a type of collar that disciplines a dog just in case he’s being really naughty or stubborn. Think of it as a small cane used to spank a child if he is misbehaving. With the best dog training collar, even an unruly dog can be easily tamed.
Now, shock collars are worn around the neck like a regular collar. The only difference is that a shock collar gives a small shock to the dog so that it behaves. Aside from that, the shock collar usually has a voice-activated speaker which lets you scold your dog from a distance.
The collar is connected to a walkie-talkie device where you can warn your dog if it is about to do something naughty. While this may sound like something that may hurt your dog, you don’t need to worry about your dog getting hurt.
The shock collar doesn’t leave any lasting pain on your dog. It just gives him a small shock that will deter him from doing anything bad like dashing across the flower bed or running after the neighbor’s cat. The whole principle behind this device is to teach the dog association.
Once the dog is used to associating with doing naughty things with a shock, he’ll most likely won’t do it anymore. You also have a speaker there that warns your dog before he’s about to do something bad. That’s another thing that your dog associates with the shock.
If you’re already sold on the idea to buy one, which one would you choose? To make choosing a lot easier, we’ve provided a list of the best dog training collars you can find in the market.
Top Picks
No products found.
You can also use the buying guide we’ve made below to help you make your decision.
How to Choose the Best Dog Training Collar
Stimulation Modes (Intensity)
This is probably the most important factor to think about when buying a dog collar. The stimulation mode determines the intensity of the collar. The more the stimulation modes, the more control you have over the intensity.
Usually, there are three main stimulation modes that most collars have: continuous, momentary, and warning. The continuous mode shocks the dog continuously (much like what an invisible dog fence does), the momentary mode sends one short shock, and the warning mode warns the dog by vibrating or ringing before the shock comes.
Others come with more advanced modes. There are some that come with run and point modes so that you can hear what your dog is doing in the walkie-talkie. The stimulation modes you want will really depend on you. Decide on what you think you need.
Collar Size
Of course, you have to take into consideration the collar size. The collar size depends on the neck size of your dog. In order to measure this, let your dog try on a collar and try to fit your two fingers inside. If the two fingers can perfectly fit between the neck and the collar, then it’s the right size.
After that, measure the size and use it as a basis when you buy your shock collar. Take note that this factor determines whether your dog is comfortable or not. This is why you have to measure accordingly.
Distance Range
The range will determine how far you can reach your dog with your device. The usual range of most training collars is ½ up to 1 mile. However, this really depends on how far you allow your dog to roam without you monitoring it. We recommend that you just stick to the standard.
Comfort
Aside from size, the material of the collar also plays a very important role in comfort. Most shock collars are made of nylon, but there are also some that are made of leather. While nylon is usually the first choice for most dog owners, not all dogs like nylon collars on them. If that’s the case, you can take the leather ones instead.
Price and Brand
The last thing that you have to think about is the price and the brand. Since this device might “hurt” your dog a little bit, you want to make sure that your dog isn’t too shocked by the collar. The cheaper ones might hurt your dog too much or might not have that many levels of control.
This is why we always recommend that you buy products from well-known brands of shock collars so that you can be assured of your dog’s safety. After all, you’re doing this to discipline your dog and not to hurt him. Therefore, you have to make sure you buy the brand that is high quality and safe.
Fortunately, all of the brands that we have below are all tried, tested, and trusted by existing dog owners. We suggest you choose one from the list below.
10 Best Dog Shock Collars
SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers
Robust Training Collar With Multiple Training Options
The exceptionally well-designed SportDOG 425 Field Trainer is a great choice for owners and dog trainers looking to utilize technology to help their dogs learn. It features a 500-yard radius and a remote that can support two additional collars. Dogs can be trained with buzzing, beeps and static stimulation that can be continuous or intermittent depending on your style.
For trainers and owners, there’s reassurance in the collars function in the rain through DryTek technology that enables the collar to stay waterproof, even through submersion in water up to 25 feet. Between uses, there’s also additional convenience in lithium ion rechargeable batteries that charge in just 2 hours, with a handy low battery indicator letting you know when it is time to recharge.
Why We Like It:
- Waterproof
- Works up to 500 yards from the remote
- Remote works on up to three collars
- Multiple training options to suit different dogs
What We Don’t Like:
- Can be tricky to program
- Can be challenging to change the settings
Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar
An Effective Training Collar with 100 Stimulation Levels
This is probably the best training collar for small dogs you can find. It has a very low level of stimulation which is good for sensitive dogs and puppies. It’s tested, trusted, and widely loved by dog lovers.
What We Like:
- A range of ½ miles
- Can fit dogs weighing 5 pounds and above
- Features a stopwatch transmitter
- Provides a vibration type stimulation
- Only requires 2 hours of charging to last it the whole day
What We Don’t Like:
- The batteries have a short shelf life of only 6 to 9 months before needing replacement
Dogtra 1900S 3/4 Mile Range 1 Dog Training Collar System
A Reliable and Fully Waterproof Option
This is one of the most comfortable dog training collars in the market. It’s made of mostly polyester and a bit of nylon to give it a rather soft texture which is comfortable on your dog’s skin. It has a very accurate stimulation of 0 up to 127 and has three main modes.
Additionally, it is designed to be fully waterproof, thus making it ideal for dogs who love swimming.
What We Like:
- Features a very precise stimulation
- It can fit dogs up to 35 pounds
- Waterproof construction
- Made of a very soft fabric
What We Don’t Like:
- Not as durable as the other brands
PATPET Waterproof Dog Training Collar P-collar 640
Long 2000 Feet Range Works Well For Hunting Dogs And Dogs Who Love To Roam
PATPET Waterproof P-Collar 640 offers trainers and owners 3 different training modes which are beeping, vibration and static. You can then fine tune these settings up to a level 16 which is the strongest setting. For hunters, trainers and pet owners who want to use the collar for long range control, the 2000 feet range of the collar is extremely handy.
Owners wanting to ensure that the collar works well in all weathers will appreciate both the collar and remote being waterproof. The product is also easy to charge with rechargeable lithium batteries designed to be long-lasting between charges.
Why We Like It:
- Multiple training modes
- Long range control
- Waterproof
- 16 strength settings
What We Don’t Like:
- Battery cannot be replaced
- Range may not be consistent
Bousnic Shock Collar for Dogs
Perfect For Yard And Park Pooches Who Need A Little Guidance
If you’re looking for a shock collar that works well within a shorter range, the waterproof PetSafe rechargeable collar could be a good choice for you. Its range is 1000 feet and is designed for dogs who walk in the park and in yards that are not extensive in distance.
Within the 1000 feet radius the collar has 3 modes to use for training which are beep, vibration and safe shock. You can then adjust these settings up to a level 16 which is the highest intensity for each training option.
Owners of multiple dogs will appreciate that the remote can work on two dogs (with additional collar purchases) and operates on dual channels for simultaneous control of both animals.
Why We Like It:
- Dual remote channels for multiple dog control
- Waterproof
- Multiple training options
- Chargeable with a phone adapter
What We Don’t Like:
- Collar can be prone to fraying
- Shock may not be effective enough for some dogs
DT Systems IDT-PLUS Micro Dog Trainer Collar
Compact and Lightweight Collar for Lightweight Use
This training collar is known for its extremely long range which can reach up to 900 yards. It also has 16 levels of stimulation which includes continuous, momentary, and gentle to mild. It allows you to train up to 3 dogs with just a single remote. It also comes with an auto shut off system for added safety.
What We Like:
- Allows you to train 3 dogs at once
- Very lightweight and compact
- Comes with long-lasting nickel rechargeable batteries
- 16 levels of stimulation
- A range of 900 yards
- Contains a safety auto shutting system
What We Don’t Like:
- Some parts are not fully waterproof
- It has transmission problems when training more than one dog
Petrainer Waterproof and Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar
The Best Value for Your Money
This dog training collar from Petrainer has a total range of 330 yards or 900 feet. This allows you to reach your dog even from a considerable distance. It can be used for various behavioral issues like excessive barking, unruly behavior, and aggression. It comes with 3 modes of training from level 0 to 100.
What We Like:
- Comes with an adjustable TPU collar width
- Very good customer service
- Waterproof design
What We Don’t Like:
- The shock may be inconsistent at times when pressed
Easy-To-Use Shock Collar System For Effective Dog Training
Pet Union PT0Z1 training collar is designed to help you easily and effectively train your pet to behave well. With a large backlit LCD remote, it is particularly easy to operate the collar, which is really handy if you’re a beginner and you’re looking for a straight-forward introduction to this kind of dog training.
The soft and durable collar has a 1,200-foot range which is really handy. It also has a 1-100 level of customization for static stimulation and vibration, and 4 different modes. These settings can be used in conjunction with a loud beep which acts as a warning for the dog, or positive reinforcement for good behavior. The various settings mean that you can base your training for bark, walk, aggression and behavior control on the kind of correction your individual dog responds best to. In most situations, the shock setting is ideal for emergency use, where your pet’s safety is compromised. Otherwise, the other settings suffice for effective day to day training.
Owners will appreciate the lithium ion battery life which lasts a long time, and charges really quickly between uses.
Why We Like It:
- Large backlit LCD remote
- Very easy to use
- 4 modes, 1-100 levels of customisation
- Long-lasting, quick-charge battery
What We Don’t Like:
- May be challenging to set up
- Scrolling to different settings during training can take a little time
Dogtra 200C Remote Training Collar
Easy-To-Use Compact Training Collar
The Dogtra 200C training collar is designed to make it as easy as possible to correct negative pet behavior. It has various advanced features, and comes with the PetsTEK clicker which enhances the training experience, and helps with positive reinforcement overall.
The collar, suitable for dogs over 10 pounds, is waterproof, which is great for active outdoor dogs. It features a handy half a mile range, and 100 training levels with momentary nick, pager vibration only and constant modes. It’s designed for low to medium intensity correction stimulation, which means it suits dogs with a low to medium temperament, and may not be suitable for dogs who need strict training intervention.
Owners will love the quick charge of the battery which only takes two hours to reach full capacity. This is really handy if you plan to have the dog wear the collar the majority of the time.
Why We Like It:
- Perfect for low to medium temperament dogs
- Waterproof
- Quick-charge battery
- Comes with handy PetsTEK clicker
What We Don’t Like:
- Battery life may not be suitable for prolonged hunting trips or other all-day walking
- Power setting is analogue which can reduce the preciseness of the settings
Dog Care Dog Training Collar
Simple And Effective Budget Dog Training Collar
The Dog Care dog training collar is a great all-rounder for owners looking to effectively control their pup on walks. It has up to 99 levels of adjustable power to suit all sizes of dog. It also features a long-lasting battery and 3 different training modes – beep, vibration and shock – for optimum choice when it comes to how you choose to train your dog.
Owners with a multi-dog household will appreciate that the remote works with three different receivers. This is great if you are looking to keep all your dogs in check with just one easy-to-use remote. Because of the 99 levels of adjustable power, you also have control over providing each pet with the correct setting for their size.
Owners will love that the collar has a great 1000 feet range, so walks in the wild won’t be a problem. It also has a long battery life, so if you’re out hunting or hiking for the day, the collar continues to work giving you consistent full control.
Why We Like It:
- 1000 feet range
- 3 training modes, 99 levels of adjustable power
- Long-lasting battery
- One remote controls up to three receivers
What We Don’t Like:
- Shock settings do not gradually increase
- Receiver is quite heavy
Benefits of Using Dog Training Collars
While dog training collars should be used wisely and sparingly, there are a few benefits that you can get from them. Of course, you have to know how to use it properly though. Even the best dog training shock collar won’t give you benefits unless it’s used the right way. In any case, here are a few benefits that you might want to know of if you’re a first timer:
They Curb Aggression
This is especially true for newly rescued dogs. Most rescued dogs have very aggressive tendencies because of the harsh treatment they received in the past. Due to this, some dogs tend to pick fights with people or even other animals like cats or dogs.
Combined with a lot of TLC, a shock collar can help curb down your dog’s aggressive behavior. The collar lets your dog associate that kind of behavior with the shock. Due to that uncomfortable feeling, your dog will tend to not want to misbehave anymore so that he can avoid feeling the shock stimulation.
They Teach Your Dog to Obey
Dogs that are very playful or have a strong personality tend to disobey their owners a lot. If you ask them to sit, they’ll usually stand up or even run around. For these types of dogs, a vibrating training collar can be useful because it disciplines them.
First, it discourages your dogs from not following your instructions. Second, it sends off some kind of warning signal in the form of a vibration. The vibration warns them that a shock will come if ever they choose to disobey your orders.
They Calm Your Dog Down During Walks
Excited dogs often run around or go crazy during walks. This can actually be prevented by using a shock collar. The shock collar would calm your dog so that you two can continue having a peaceful walk. At the same time, you can control his behavior.
They Allow You to Train More Than One Dog at a Time
If all your dogs have shock collars, you can train all of them at the same time. If dog A is misbehaving, train him with a small shock. If dog B misbehaves at the same time, you’ve got another remote to control his collar too.
They Allow You to Monitor Your Dog from a Distance
One of the best benefits of having the best remote dog training collar is that you can monitor your dog from a distance. Most shock collars have built-in microphones that allow you to hear what your dog is doing. Hence, if your dog is eating plants while you’re in the house, you’ll somehow get an idea of what he’s doing.
FAQs
Q: Are training collars safe? Will they hurt your dog?
A: Generally, dog collars are very safe since they don’t really hurt your dog by any means. What they do is give your dog a slightly uncomfortable stimulation. This is done so that your dog associates misbehavior with that uncomfortable feeling.
Also, the best shock collar brands are known to have control settings that allow you to control the mode and intensity of the shock. As long as you keep the shock to a minimum, then you don’t have to worry about hurting your dog.
However, just to be safe, we don’t recommend that you buy shock collars that come from unknown brands. If you want to be assured of quality, get the known ones like the ones we’ve mentioned in our list.
Q: How long should I train my dog using training collar?
A: This is an age-old question that a lot of beginners ask whenever they want to know how long they should use a dog collar. Most pet owners would use the dog collar for a total of 20 minutes a day so that they won’t stress out their dog. You can split the 20 minutes into two sessions. The first session would be 10 minutes while the second session is 10 minutes as well.
However, during the first few sessions, you might want to allocate 20 minutes so that you can get used to using the collar. The next few minutes can be used for your dog training.
Q: How do I know what stimulation level to use?
A: The stimulation level refers to the intensity level of the shock used. In order to test which stimulation level is best for your dog, test it on yourself first. Put the collar on yourself and test out which one stings a bit. Take note that your dog is much more sensitive than you are, so if you put a level 4 setting, your dog might feel a level 8.
After that, try it out on your dog. Test it out on the lowest level first and see which one fits your dog. The idea is to sting just a little bit. You should just spook your dog a bit and not hurt him. Once you find that level, just stick to it.
Q: How old should my dog be before using a training collar?
A: As a rule of thumb, don’t use a shock collar on a puppy that’s less than 10 weeks old as much as possible. It’s quite possible to actually traumatize the puppy by exposing it to such a shock at a very young age. Hence, it’s better that you wait for your puppy to reach 10 weeks old before using a shock collar.
However, you might want to try positive reinforcement first. Try to discipline him by using a dog leash and some snacks. If they work, you won’t need to use bark collars or shock collars anymore.
Q: How long can my dog wear a training collar?
A: You might be tempted to leave the training collar on your dog for a long time during the day so that you can monitor him wherever he goes. However, you may also want to consider taking it out after 12 hours.
If your dog associates the collar with something bad, then he obviously won’t like the collar around its neck. In order to prevent upsetting your dog, you shouldn’t leave it there for more than 12 hours. You may also want to spread out the time you’ll be leaving the shock collar there so you won’t upset your dog too much.
Conclusion
Your dog might get a little spooked out by the shock collar; however, a little bit of discomfort is necessary to discipline him if he’s exhibiting any unruly behavior. Don’t think of using the shock collar as a form of punishment; instead, use it is a form of reinforcement.
That said, it’s very important that you buy the best dog training collar with the highest quality features available. At least with those features, you can control how much discomfort or shock you give. You don’t want to scare your dog too much now, would you?
5 Replies to “The Best Dog Training Collars in 2022”
If you love animals, why would a shock collar be your best option? Positive reinforcement and working with your dog, builds your bond and helps your pup to understand what you want from them.
There really handy to let your dogs of the leash and when they are too far to hear your voice they fill the vibration you don’t need to use the shock feature
Not always. Some dogs are more stubborn by nature than others. I have NEVER had to use a shocker on a dog, until I got my new puppy. She’s 7 months old and will LOOK at me telling her to stop and keep going…. straight into the road. I’d much rather have control of a shock collar than no control with her in the road. Plus, she responds to vibration so we don’t have to shock. The vibration startles her enough to bring her back.
Curious about some comments on the range of these devices.
Pet Care Dog Training Collar
What We Don’t Like:
It has a limited range of only 330 yards
And yet the Petrainer Waterproof and Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar
What We Like:
A range of 330 yards
Both have the same range but it’s good for one and not the other?
Sorry. Mistakes were made. Removed it from pros.